Clive is so great. He's just a little guy who wants to be an edgy loner so bad, but he cant help it. He just wants everyone to be safe and happy. Not counting 14, I've only ever played the 7 remake, and Clive is a nice contrast to Cloud.
Don't get me wrong, Cloud has a similar vibe. But like Clive talks, and smiles, and he gets a little awkward when people flirt with him. He compliments people who do good things, and his dialog during side quests shows he's genuinely concerned with the well-being of people around him.
It's just nice to have a Clive to play. Like I've done lots of Zelda lately, and Link's personality was never the draw. D:OS and Baldur's Gate 3 both have protagonists that like to veer into "hard person for a hard world". Elden Ring is Elden Ring.
Give me the protagonist who is human enough to be affected by the world, but also actually nice and stuff.