@Shyfer @Lianodel I listened to The Critshow do Monster of the Week when I was running my first campaign with it. I like the agenda and moves. The first couple sessions were like you said, trying to play a different game, but once it clicked, I loved it.
(Reminding me I need to run that next one I wrote sometime)
@slyflourish My most used accessory is a Pathfinder magnetic Combat Pad I bought back in 2011. Little magnets I can write on with wet erase markers, then shuffle around to make the initiative, plus space to scribble with wet-erase to track hp and stuff.
Fantastic tool.