It seems the majority of the torrents with poor seeder count are in the 1.5TB+ range. I just simply don't have the storage for that. Most everything in the 0-300GB range is pretty well covered.
this post was submitted on 16 Nov 2023
305 points (100.0% liked)
Piracy: ꜱᴀɪʟ ᴛʜᴇ ʜɪɢʜ ꜱᴇᴀꜱ
1445 readers
17 users here now
⚓ Dedicated to the discussion of digital piracy, including ethical problems and legal advancements.
Rules • Full Version
1. Posts must be related to the discussion of digital piracy
2. Don't request invites, trade, sell, or self-promote
3. Don't request or link to specific pirated titles, including DMs
4. Don't submit low-quality posts, be entitled, or harass others
Loot, Pillage, & Plunder
📜 c/Piracy Wiki (Community Edition):
💰 Please help cover server costs.
 |
 |
|---|---|
| Ko-fi | Liberapay |
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Agreed. I'd like to share a bit of disk storage but I only have 2 TB and I need that for my own consumption.
Give us smaller torrents (e.g. 50GB parts) instead.
You can easilly select those files from a given torrent which you would like to download and seed.
How do you make the torrent software automatically rotate which content it preserves based on the files with the fewest copies in the Swarm ? I don't want to manage this manually or have to select files by hand.
That's an answer I don't have. I would just focus on grabbing what has the fewest copies for the snap-shot in time when I am downloading the files. Other archivers will grab what needs more copies at the time they download, just as you and I are basing our downloads of what has the fewest existing copies weighed against what others have seeded before us.
Its a churn of archivers "rotating" the content we each choose to preserve(almost entirely without regard for WHAT the specific content is).
If enough people were too active about deleting what they've downloaded that has "enough" copies and replacing it with content that doesn't ... okay, that's unlikely, but we still need more seeders in general, and those of us who keep on seeding that which we've already downloaded make the decision of what needs more copies seeded in the future easier to make for new archivists and/or those who have invested in more capacity.
Answered already here: https://lemmy.dbzer0.com/comment/5155010
Already well enough seeded.
Also: Partial downloads on torrents are ~~evil~~not great^reason for the change. (Still) Don't do that.
Edit: Updated my stance on partial download.
Why are partial downloads evil?
Being not a full seeder you are only giving what you have.
If another seeder quits, nobody can complete the torrent.
Not great.
Okay, but you're providing more to the swarm than if you weren't participating.
True. Can't argue with that logic because I use it as well
Not great isn't the same as evil. They're still sharing what they have.
I updated my comment. I kindly ask for feedback if possible
This is a bad take, I want to auto seed the last 1% of every torrent which is the least available and automatically rotate it. Torrent infrastructure needs to stop sucking.
How do I do this? When I open up the magnet link, it only seems to give me one checkbox for the entire 10 TB thing. Sure, I can check "download first and last parts before anything else" but it would still try to download all 10 TB, no?
Edit: Nevermind, I didn't grab one of the files that has aac in its name.
Me with only 250GB ssd in an intel nuc lmao
That's my rented seedbox I sync my downloads from.
At home I have an intel nuc 11th gen with 8tb attached via USB.
There are smaller torrents < 80gb go take a look on their website
Those have enough seeds for now.
Can you partially seed some of a larger torrent?
Yes. When downloading the torrent, go to the files list for that torrent and un-check boxes. Resist the urge to leave only the first files in the list(as most people will do this leaving few-if-anyone seeding the rest), **and try instead to grab files from the middle or end, or just be random about it.
When the torrent finishes downloading the files you've selected, it will automatically seed those portions of the torrent which you have downloaded.
EDIT: I just remembered, some torrent programs will actually show you the seed ratio per file in the torrent. There are reasons hardly anyone is (sincerely) trying to reinvent this wheel.
This is too much work, someone automate this with the smartest algorithm and I will preserve with the power of 10x 2tb 10gbe seedbox.
Automatically auto seed on a rotation the 10% least available file of each torrent Percentage should be adjustable globally and per torrent.
This is true, but I don’t know if you’d be counted as a seeder on that list though if you don’t have the full torrent.
Bruh, this is a terrible way to share this. Why not torrents of the raw material in predefined categories that won't change? Like "1984 - Sci-Fi - English - A-N", "1984 - Sci-Fi - English - O-Z", "1990 - Biology", "2012 - Physics". Then people would actually even download this to use it themselves, instead of some archive that has to be extracted and will take a multitude of the space again.
The hell am I going to do with a 300GB archive file that I cannot even look into? I might as well be storing an encrypted blob 300GB large or just reducing the size of my partition by 300GB.
It's great that people want to preserve human knowledge, but there surely are better ways to do this.
If you can do better let's see it. This post is for altruists and archivists... clearly you're neither.
This is just bad communication, beating down on people that are delivering constructive criticism.
Way to gatekeep. Don't you think it would be better if more people could contribute bandwidth and storage with what they have instead of buy a new hardrive? Wouldn't you want more redundancy, instead of less?
I don't think they use an indexable compression as well, right? That essentially kills stuff for me.
The easiest way to host is not TB/PB sized archives but indices and slices for those.
It easier for a lot of us to download a few gigs and share that, rather than download TB/PB sized archives.
WTF he’s raising a good point
Who thought it was a good idea to have single torrents of multiple TB??
It's unclear to me how these torrents are used. If individual books are not downloaded from them, is this only to make it possible to create similar sites in the future, in case this one is taken down?
They are meant for long-term preservation.
This is basically a "distributed backup" of the entire database. The torrents are not actively serving files- they're there to store multiple copies of the main database across the globe so that the entire database can be recovered (by anyone with the requisite knowledge, mind you) in the event that something happens to the original Anna's Archive team or the main database is lost/seized by "law enforcement".
It's equivalent to how backup managers in ye olden days would make broken up piece files of a certain size that could fit onto a CD or DVD, so you could fit the entire contents of a large 20+GB hard drive onto multiple smaller media. The backup itself is not accessed unless your main hard drive crashes, in which case you reassemble all the individual pieces back into your complete OS environment after replacing the hard drive.
Unfortunately I don't have enough storage space to seed. Is there any other way to help?
The torrents are broken up into smaller pieces - don't be intimidated by the big TB numbers from the sum total. Otherwise donations are always useful.
donate!
Id happily seed a tb or so of the most in-danger torrents. My internet aint much but my old pc is almost always on.
How do I know which of the piece torrents are high or low on seeders? Maybe I'm just being special or can't see it on mobile but is there no way to check each torrent's health without actually downloading every piece and putting it in my torrent client?
The health is listed next to each piece at this URL: https://annas-archive.org/torrents
Ah perfect. I'll throw some of the 300gb archives on my rig when I get home.
Just got a 300gb torrent to seed for a while. It won't be on 24/7 but most of the day it will.
I'd gladly donate a few TB, but Not about to fill my entire array for books i'll never read...
I'll set this up this weekend, thanks for the heads up (salute emoji)
🫡
Is a seedbox necessary or will qbittorrent with a VPN work?
that works!
Still seeding strong! 
Maybe i should format my windows drive i haven't touched in a year and throw 3 internet archive torrents on there.