My top 11 (as I've seen 11):
- Evil Dead Rise
- Renfield
- M3gan
- Scream VI
- Unwelcome
- Knock at the Cabin
- The Poughkeepsie Tapes
- Pearl
- Infinity Pool
- The Boogeyman
- The Pope's Exorcist
Sisu and The Missing aren't listed as horror on IMDb. I also "missed" Beau is Afraid (got a better offer, which from word of mouth wasn't difficult) and it got such a short, late run it was pretty much a one night only thing in my local cinema.
edit: formatting