I love Telltale's stuff, but they're a bit hit or miss for me. I really liked The Wolf Among Us and Tales from the Borderlands, but really didn't care for The Walking Dead sequels and Batman. A lot of companies tried to replicate what they had but they never had writing as good.
That said, Telltale really needed some alternate endings. There's only so much "X will remember this" I can read before I realize how little my actions matter.
I'm sadly not optimistic that The Wolf Among Us 2 is ever coming out. They laid off most of their staff half a year ago.